Welcome to The Storied Recipe! The recipe for this award-winning Homemade Cinnamon & Brown Sugar bread comes from Liz Mulligan. Her grandmother packed loaves of this delicious cinnamon swirl bread into a wagon and brought it around to neighbors in her midwestern small town. Make sure you listen to Liz's episode while you make her grandmother's delicious brown sugar bread!
This bread is SO delicious I made 6 loaves that were gobbled down by my familybefore I could finally photograph one!
One tip from my podcast guest, Liz: Always toast her Cinnamon Brown Sugar Bread and slather with butter.
Truthfully, I didn't think the bread could get any better than the soft, gooey goodness that comes straight from the oven. But Liz was right: toasting the bread brought out the most beautiful golden color, a richer flavor, and made the gooey brown sugar in the filling warm and caramelized.
Enjoy a slice of this sweet bread with a cup of coffee for the perfect breakfast on a chilly fall morning.
Or, just like Liz's grandmother, make gifts of these gorgeous loaves!
For more uses, jump to How To Use in the outline below:
Jump to:
- What to Expect:
- How to Enjoy the Best Cinnamon Swirl Bread
- Listen to Liz's Warm Memories
- Follow The Storied Recipe in Your Favorite Player
- Ingredients
- Instructions
- Substitutions & Variations
- Top tip
- Equipment
- Storage
- More Breads from Around the World
- More Breakfast Recipes from Around the World
- Best Homemade Cinnamon & Brown Sugar Bread Recipe
What to Expect:
- This is a recipe for a yeasted bread, NOT a quick bread, so the structure is open and fluffy.
- Yeasted breads are good for all sorts of uses beyond toasting - see below!
How to Enjoy the Best Cinnamon Swirl Bread
- As Liz and her family attest, this Cinnamon Brown Sugar Bread goes to another level when it's toasted!! Butter is the best complement to the fluffy bread and brown sugar flavor.
- Use to make French toast topped with maple syrup or fluffy powdery sugar
- Use to make the best Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwich ever!!
- Or - my favorite! - Cream Cheese and Jelly Sandwich
- Use these pretty small tins and make mini loaves for holiday gifts (or any time of the year).
- Make cinnamon rolls: Roll the dough more thinly (about ¼ inch) and cover with the brown sugar mixture. Roll up the long way. Slice into spirals about 1" (one inch) high and place in a pan with at least an inch between each roll. (But honestly, if you want to make cinnamon rolls... use The Pioneer Woman's recipe. It cannot be beat.)
Listen to Liz's Warm Memories
This award-winning recipe for Brown Sugar Cinnamon Bread is over 50 years old and locally famous in a small town in Michigan. The recipe and its developer, Virginia Dayton, were featured in multiple newspaper articles.
Virginia's granddaughter Liz shares all about her memories of eating this bread her her grandmother's old white farmhouse. Tune in to this heartwarming - but surprisingly raw and vulnerable - interview with Liz.
005 Baking Bread with Grandmother in an Old White Farmhouse
Follow The Storied Recipe in Your Favorite Player
Ingredients
Homemade cinnamon swirl bread sounds fancy, but I'd be money there's nothing here that you don't already have in your pantry!
Homemade Bread Ingredients
- Hot water
- Shortening
- White sugar
- Salt
- Egg
- Active dry yeast or instant yeast (either work fine.)
- All purpose flour (bread flour is not necessary for this rustic recipe.)
Filling Ingredients
- Shortening
- Dark brown sugar (more flavor than light brown sugar)
- Cinnamon
See recipe card for quantities.
Instructions
Although this is a yeast bread, don't be intimidated! Truthfully this is an easy cinnamon bread recipe for beginners. Brown sugar covers a multitude of mistakes in this recipe!
Make the Bread Dough
- Sprinkle Active Dry yeast in lukewarm water to activate.
- Melt shortening in hot water.
- Combine sugar, salt, egg, and yeast
- Gradually mix in flour.
- First rise: Let the dough rise until doubled in size.
Shape and Fill the Loaves
- Grease two loaf pans.
- Divide the dough into two sections
- Roll (or simply use hands to flatten) one section on a floured board.
- Roll the dough and place into prepared loaf pan, ensuring the seam is on top.
- Repeat with the second section
- Second rise: Let rise until doubled.
Bake the Cinnamon Brown Sugar Bread
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
- Brush the top of the bread with an egg yolk mixed with water.
- Bake for 30 minutes.
- Cool on a wire rack.
Substitutions & Variations
This is a very simple & basic homemade cinnamon bread. My best advice is to keep it that way.
- Mix butter rather than shortening with cinnamon sugar mixture
- Cinnamon Raisin Bread: After you've spread the cinnamon brown sugar paste on the bread dough, sprinkle ¼ cup of raisins over the for cinnamon raisin bread
Top tip
- Virginia's recipe was rustic and had a soft white top. Add an egg wash for a shiny golden brown color.
- Cover the top with aluminum foil if it gets too dark before baked through.
Equipment
- Standard loaf tins
- Mini or decorative holiday loaf tins
Storage
- Can place in an airtight container or wrapped in plastic wrap on counter for 48 hours
- Freezes wonderfully!
- Freeze the loaves after the 2nd rise, before baking. Place in pan and bake from frozen. Add 10 minutes to bake time.
- Alternatively, freeze after baking. Set on counter to thaw for 2 hours.
More Breads from Around the World
More Breakfast Recipes from Around the World
Best Homemade Cinnamon & Brown Sugar Bread Recipe
Difficulty: Easy8
servings2
hours30
minutes2
hours30
minutesBest homemade Cinnamon Swirl & Brown Sugar Bread - the best bread for toast!! Slather with butter or make the best peanut butter and jelly sandwich ever!
Keep the screen of your device on
Ingredients
Bread Ingredients
¼ cup lukewarm water PLUS
2 c 2 hot water
2 tablespoon 2 shortening
2 tablespoon 2 white sugar
2 teaspoon 2 salt
1 1 egg
1 envelope 1 dry yeast
5 5 to 6 cups flour
Filling Ingredients
4 tablespoon 4 shortening
1 1 ½ cup brown sugar
2 tablespoon 2 cinnamon
Directions
- Make the Bread Dough
- Activate yeast in ¼ cup lukewarm water and set aside.
- Melt the shortening in the 2 cups hot water in a large bowl and allow to cool to lukewarm.
- Add sugar, salt, egg, and softened yeast.
- Using a stand mixer with a dough hook OR by hand, stir in 2 cups of flour and mix well, then continue to add flour, a little at a time, and continue to mix.
- When too stiff to stir, knead in the remaining flour, a little at a time, until it is no longer sticky.
- First Rise: Place in a lightly oiled or greased bowl. Cover and let stand in warm place out of draft until double in size.
- Shape the Loaves
- Knead down and cut into two sections, placing one section on a floured board. Press as flat as possible with your hands.
- Meanwhile grease a loaf pan with PAM spray or butter.
- With a spatula, spread 2 tablespoons shortening over dough. Sprinkle 1 tablespoon cinnamon and ¾ cup brown sugar over the dough. Roll the dough like a jelly roll and fold each end up to the middle to form a loaf to fit into a 5×9 inch bread pan, making sure that the seam of the roll is on the top, so that the filling will not run out while baking.
- Second rise: Place in prepared loaf pan and set in a warm place until double in size. Repeat this procedure for a second loaf.
- Bake
- Meanwhile, preheat oven to 350 degrees.
- For a glossy brown top, brush top of the loaf with an egg yolk mixed with 2 tablespoon of water
- Bake in a preheated oven for 30 minutes.
- Remove from oven immediately and allow to cool on a wire rack.
- Serve
- Cut generously slices. Toast until crunchy and golden. Slather with butter. Enjoy!!
Notes
- Make sure you listen to Liz's episode, Virginia Dayton’s Brown Sugar Cinnamon Bread while you make her Brown Sugar Cinnamon Bread
Did you make this recipe?
Tag @thestoriedrecipe.podcast on Instagram and hashtag it #thestoriedrecipe
Like this recipe?
Follow us @thestoriedrecipe on Pinterest
Would love to hear from you!